diff --git a/PluralKit.Bot/Commands/Groups.cs b/PluralKit.Bot/Commands/Groups.cs
index b9eb60b6..b93bd55a 100644
--- a/PluralKit.Bot/Commands/Groups.cs
+++ b/PluralKit.Bot/Commands/Groups.cs
@@ -471,7 +471,7 @@ namespace PluralKit.Bot
             }
             else return; // otherwise toAction "may be undefined"
 
-            await ctx.Reply(GroupAddRemoveResponseService.GenerateResponse(op, members.Count, 1, members.Count - existingMembersInGroup.Count, existingMembersInGroup.Count));
+            await ctx.Reply(GroupAddRemoveResponseService.GenerateResponse(op, members.Count, 1, toAction.Count, members.Count - toAction.Count));
         }
 
         public async Task ListGroupMembers(Context ctx, PKGroup target)
diff --git a/PluralKit.Bot/Commands/MemberGroup.cs b/PluralKit.Bot/Commands/MemberGroup.cs
index e324f233..37cdc281 100644
--- a/PluralKit.Bot/Commands/MemberGroup.cs
+++ b/PluralKit.Bot/Commands/MemberGroup.cs
@@ -55,7 +55,7 @@ namespace PluralKit.Bot
             }
             else return; // otherwise toAction "may be unassigned"
 
-            await ctx.Reply(GroupAddRemoveResponseService.GenerateResponse(op, 1, groups.Count, groups.Count - existingGroups.Count, existingGroups.Count));
+            await ctx.Reply(GroupAddRemoveResponseService.GenerateResponse(op, 1, groups.Count, toAction.Count, groups.Count - toAction.Count));
         }
 
         public async Task List(Context ctx, PKMember target)